It is dangerous to joke in India

By Justice Katju
Although most of my articles and posts are serious, sometimes, to create a lighter atmosphere, I joke too.
But joking is dangerous in India, and my habit of joking has often got me into trouble, as most Indians have little or no sense of humour. and this, too, has contributed to me being described as a ‘controversial judge’.
https://m.thewire.in/article/humour/jokes-india-humour
Consider these examples :
(1) I once wrote on my facebook page that since Pakistanis have been adamantly demanding Kashmir for long, we should tell them that they can have it, provided they take Bihar with it too.
Now anyone with even a little commonsense would have understood that this was a joke. How can a retired person like me give Bihar to Pakistan ? And Bihar is not contiguous to Pakistan, like Kashmir, Punjab, Gujarat or Rajasthan that it could be given to Pakistan.
I also said ( again in lighter vein ) ” Hindustan ko khatra Pakistan se nahi hai, Bihar se hai ”. Actually these were the words of my English Professor Firaq Gorakhpuri ( the famous Urdu poet ) in the Allahabad University, when I was a student there.
It so happened that once Firaq was invited to a mushaira in some city in Bihar. The people in the audience could not understand Urdu, so they hooted him. Being short tempered, Firaq then uttered those words ( which I only repeated in lighter vein ).
But the Indian media furiously attacked me, saying I had done ‘ghor apmaan’ ( great insult ) to Bihar
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1ASWcXxwSI&pp=ygUha2F0anUgZ2l2ZSBiaWhhciB0byBwYWtpc3RhbiBhbWFu0gcJCeoHAYcqIYzv
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QSh-LqbfVxM&pp=ygULa2F0anUgYmloYXI%3D
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6k7qnSudRUo&pp=ygUca2F0anUgZ2l2ZSBiaWhhciB0byBwYWtpc3Rhbg%3D%3D
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TD2grs-y6J4&pp=ygUca2F0anUgZ2l2ZSBiaWhhciB0byBwYWtpc3Rhbg%3D%3D
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7iQ5UTpbyM&pp=ygUfa2F0anUgb2ZmZXJzIGJpaGFyIHRvIHBha2lzdGFuIA%3D%3D
Biharis got very upset at my statements, and processions were taken out on the streets of many cities of Bihar. In these protests and processions, posters of my face were blackened, and my effigies burnt ( possibly if I had been in Bihar at that time I may have been burnt too ).
The Chief Minister of Bihar, Nitish Kumar, castigated me, asking whether I am Bihar’s ‘mai baap’ ?
An FIR for sedition was also filed against me
During this controversy I was once at the Delhi airport lounge where I met Ms. Meira Kumar, who was the Speaker of the Lok Sabha ( the lower House of Parliament ) and is herself from Bihar. I told her I had only joked about giving Bihar to Pakistan. She smiled at me and said ” Katju saheb, ab aap kuch din Bihar mat jaaiyega ” ( Justice Katju, don’t go to Bihar for some time ).
Ultimately, following the dictum ‘discretion is the better part of valour’, and to put a quietus to the matter, I decided to apologize to Biharis (for cracking a joke).
(2) After the above incident, some Odiyas asked me to write something about their state Odisha. So I wrote this on my Facebook page:
”I was asked to write about the Oriyas (Odiyas). What is there to write about these poor chaps ? Ever since they got a thrashing at the hands of Emperor Ashoka in the battle of Kalinga about 2300 years ago, they have been a dejected lot. Now all they have with them are a lot of pots (Patras), big pots (Mahapatras), and supposedly intelligent kings (Patnaiks). And of course, they have Lord Jaggannath, to whom they pray every day for revenge on the abominable Biharis.
Hari Om
P.S.
Odiyas, this is just a joke, so don’t file a case against me.”
I specifically mentioned at the end of my post that this was just a joke, so that a defamation case is not filed against me ( as had been done in Bihar ).
But again there was a hue and cry, this time by Odiyas, for being ‘insulted’.
Again I beat a hasty retreat and apologised.
(3) I once cracked this Sardarji joke on my facebook page :
” A Sardarji was invited to a dinner party. The invitation card mentioned ‘Black ties only’.
When the Sardarji reached the party he found men wearing shirts and pants also ”.
Some Sikhs, on reading this post, filed a petition in the Supreme Court praying for a direction to ban Sardarji jokes, and registering a criminal case against me.
The Court referred the matter to Justice HS Bedi, a retired Supreme Court Judge, for his opinion. Justice Bedi, who was himself a Sikh, reported that the petition was frivolous. He said that though a Sikh, he himself often cracked Sardarji jokes. The petition was thereupon dismissed.
(4) I once wrote on my fb page ( again as a joke ) that Bengalis should find a good husband for Mamata Banerjee ( the then Chief Minister of West Bengal ), to cool her down.
At this Kunal Ghosh, a senior member of Mamata Banerjee’s TMC party, commented ” If Justice Katju comes to West Bengal I will slap him on his face ”.
(5) A lady lawyer once asked me for some tips how to argue in Court.
I said in reply ” Behes karte hue Judge ko aankh maar do ”
i.e.
” While arguing, wink at the judge ”.
The consequence was that the Supreme Court Women Lawyers Association called an emergency meeting, in which speaker after speaker roundly condemned me as a misogynist, and stated that such comments were not merely offensive but an assault on the dignity, credibility, competence, integrity and professional standing of every woman in the legal fraternity.
The SCWLA demanded my apology, and passed this resolution in the stormy meeting :
” It is deeply disturbing that a former judge of the Supreme Court, who once entrusted with the responsibility of upholding constitutional values, would trivialize the hard work and merit of women lawyers through casual sexism. His words not only demean women advocates but also erode public confidence in the impartiality of the justice system and perpetuate harmful stereotypes that have no place in a democratic society. Coming from a former Judge of the Supreme Court, they are particularly shocking and unbecoming of the dignity associated with constitutional office”,
I promptly apologised, adding that I had only been joking
(7) Another example is of a joke I cracked about Chaturvedis.
Chaturvedis claim to be Brahmins, but traditionally a Chaturvedi boy can only marry a Chaturvedi girl. Other Brahmins of North India such as Shukla, Mishra, Dwivedi, Trivedi, Pandey, Vajpayi, etc, do not marry a Chaturvedi.
So I cracked a joke that Chaturvedis are not Brahmins at all, but are Greeks that have descended from the soldiers of the army of Alexander the Great, who invaded India in 326 B.C.
To conclude, let me tell this joke on myself. I am a Brahmin, and I once said ”Brahman 60 saal tak ponga rehta hai, aur uske baad sathiya jaata hai.” i.e.
A Brahman is a fool till 60, after which he becomes senile.
Those Brahmins who have no sense of humor will surely file a defamation case against me. My defense will be that since I am 80, I am senile, and hence non-compos mentis !
Note: Justice Markandey Katju is a format judge of the Suprim Court of India.
Share this content:



Post Comment